
Does hearing the words Lead in Lipstick make you cringe?
Lead in Lipstick (Fact)
Is it a controversy? No, it’s a proven fact! The FDA released information regarding their 2010 testing of 400 lipsticks. All contained lead. Isn’t lead a bad thing? Then why is it in our lipstick?
Lipstick is one of the only makeup products we can ingest. The FDA researchers say that the PPM (parts per million) in lipstick stays within the regulated guide lines, and that we don’t ingest enough of it to cause a problem. Well, dear FDA how would you know? Did you conduct any clinical trials to stand behind such a statement? Common sense would tell you that if it’s on the mouth then were eating it, even if we don’t mean to. Think about what lipstick you’re wearing when you eat, drink, kiss, chew gum, or spit. Now I know we can’t ingest the entirety of what is on our mouth, because half is wiped off. However, we are ingesting a good percentage and as that may not hurt you once or twice, what about a lifetime? Women are not just wearing lipsticks once and while, but every day for hours at a time. So accumulatively we are building up a lead level that doesn’t need to be there.
Lead is a nasty beast found in many things, even our soil. Plants are being grown out of polluted soil and we eat those plants. So is it possible to escape lead? Probably not, but we can limit our exposure to it. We as humans can not, and are not, in control of everything. What we can do is react. There is no reason for any amount of lead to be found in our lipsticks. It has even been found in Cosmetic Foundation! So what are we to do? Stop wearing these favorite products of ours? Its hard enough picking things that work let alone adding ingredient formulations to our decision making. So what are we to do?
The best thing any of us makeup, skin care, product consumers can do is limit our exposure. Evaluate what we are wearing and who it is made by. We can not live our lives consumed by fear, worry, and dread. However, we can use common sense.
Another move is looking into companies with good report. Who follow the strictest of guidelines and try to put people first, instead of the dollar. Research which companies are practicing what they preach. Read the ingredients and try to locate ones you wish to avoid. This rule changes upon individual preference. Some may worry over parabens, some may not. If you do not like parabens then do yourself a favour and avoid it. I have been asked questions on good vs evil when it comes to formulations in cosmetic ingredients. There is no right answer, because its individual. The best I can do is share my opinion, and pass it on. (Please see ‘Which Side are You on?’ post for further information)
I will tell you from my own personal research that I am not an avoider of all things. I am of some. I feel that fragrance is an ingredient, if its synthetic, to be avoided. Fragrance can cause irritation in many individuals and irritation leads to inflammation. Inflammation causes redness and accelerates the aging process. Another is formaldehyde. Formaldehyde releasers are found in everything from baby shampoo to moisturizers. They are used as a preservative to keep bacteria away. I do not fear formaldehyde in itself (it’s formed naturally in nature) but I do its effects. It too is a known irritant and I just explained what irritation can lead too. With that said, it is still found in half the stuff I own. I’m searching for things that do not contain Formaldehyde, but not fretting about.
We need to remember it’s not what we use from time to time that is a problem but what we use everyday over many years. Even certain sun screens have been found to build up in our tissues after continued use and are harmful to our bodies. This doesn’t mean go without it! It means sourcing information, looking into clinical studies, and purchasing the appropriate product. It is a lot of work, and very time-consuming. Who has time for all this? That is why we put our trust into the administrations that govern the factories out-putting our products.
Here’s a shocker though. That ‘Administration’ we put our trust into, has little interaction within the cosmetics industry. It has only ruled over a few things, and for the most part allows the companies to govern themselves. The FDA will only step in when enough of a problem over a product has been found to be dangerous to the health of an individual/individuals. It is up to us to sound off. The Cosmetic Review Board, which is an organization under the FDA, is responsible for following through and checking up on the guidelines these manufactures are ‘supposed’ to follow. The sad fact is they only have a voice, no power. They set the standard and make suggestions, but its left up to the companies to uphold themselves to that standard and make an honest product. Again, what to do?
Ingredient Savvy
Mrs Susan with four small children doesn’t have the time to scan every product on the shelf for safe ingredients. Even if she could, would she know what she’s reading? Ingredients can be overwhelming and without being a chemist, are hard to understand. Not to mention 1 or 2 different ingredients on their own may be safe but mixed together can create a dangerous cocktail. How are we supposed to know these things as a consumer? We can’t, and we don’t have the time. We are not all chemist and makeup guru’s. We have to trust someone. That’s where we start.
- Start with products you trust. Get acquainted with certain ingredients by ‘Googling’ them. Making an educated decision will help equip you when choosing a cosmetic product. It doesn’t have to be so black and white. Not everything is harmful. Find your gray area. What your comfortability is. After all it is your body, and you should have a choice in the matter.
My opinion is nothing that can cause cancer, or build up to toxic levels should enter our cosmetic products. NO EXCEPTIONS! I have seen so many problems arise from irritation. Having an allergic reaction to food is one thing, but it shouldn’t happen from our makeup. I feel that the FDA has too much on their hands to truly be concerned with lead in lipstick. Especially if the PPM are kept to requirement. I do not agree with their approach and wish they would take it more seriously. It is ingested, and it does start to cause a problem after many years of use. As a civilization we have crossed hazardous roads before. Take asbestos for example. It was ‘supposed’ to be so safe. For goodness sake it was meant for fire-proofing, but what eventually happened? Cancer.
Websites to look into
The Skin Deep Data base (SDD) is a great place to start if searching for safer products is something your interested in. They narrow it down, and give you an honest idea of what to look for using a numbered scale. 0-3 for good 3-6 for okay 7-9 as bad. Please be aware. Even though the SDD creators have the best of intentions they do not have all the clinical information to back up some of their warnings. Don’t let what you read scare you. Instead, research it for yourself. If you agree with them, then adjust accordingly.
Another good source is the Campaign for Safe Cosmetics. For a company to sign their campaign act they must adhere to strict guidelines, follow protocol, and be environmentally friendly. They must maintain these standards yearly, and are consistently checked in upon. If they stop doing what they are supposed to then they are removed from the list. Two cosmetic companies that have signed and been a member for years is Zosimos Botanicals and Jane Iredale. Both are mineral makeup companies and produce a lot of product. These are just some examples, and many other’s have signed the act.
Trusting Companies
Trusting a company before a purchase is made can make you feel more secure. Any brand can have its good and bad side. Don’t fret if you find this to be true when making a decision. Instead of writing them off completely just choose another product from their line that meets your standards. I love Aveda and Origins (both are owned by Estee Lauder) but even though they claim to be all natural they aren’t entirely. Some of their ingredients fall short, or have an added preservative. This doesn’t make them bad, it just makes me weed out what I don’t want, and be aware.
Be careful, realistic, educated, and informed on making your choices. Find what works for you, and trust what you purchase. We are all individuals and make our decisions based upon that. Don’t be pushed around, or scared into/out-of something. Knowing is half the battle.
With Beauty’s Best,
Angel-a